So we have more info on the live-action of GitS

Discuss whatever
Post Reply
Algazero
Not So Newb
Not So Newb
Posts: 7
Joined: Sat Oct 10, 2015 8:34 am

So we have more info on the live-action of GitS

Post by Algazero » Tue Nov 15, 2016 6:51 pm

We have a trailer out now as well as the "opening" scene featuring the "shelling" (as the crew called it) of the "Major". So let's go ahead and discuss it here where we have no need to worry about character limits. Whitewashing aside, I'll focus on the contents of what has been released to us so far.
Here's the trailer for those who wish to view it.
I don't have much to say on this one other than the trailer looks too bland/the same as what we already had in animated form. I do recognize a lot of the city from the original Oshii film which is fine, but the trailer as a whole looks to play it way too safe and looks to appeal to the lowest common denominator just to make cash. Hoping to maybe get a tank or tachikoma in here somewhere. We also have the problem that maybe they're going to play into a conspiracy or lie, with the last lines of the Puppetmaster in the trailer, which goes against what film/manga Major were seeking to do. We also have the geisha robots from Innocence in there as well for some reason...

And here we have the "shelling" clip.
An interesting take on the "shelling" as they called it, I however don't like the "actiony" take on the "birth" of the Major. The original film depicted a delicate, slow, tedious process that the original film and music understood perfectly. This version features a sequence of flashes akin to a flashback as opposed to focusing on the creation of the Major, and while the Kawai's music is still being used here, it is altered to give the sense of action and ramps up the tempo and spends less time on the crafting of the cyborg that we'll come to know.
Thoughts?
Searching for Silent Hill...
Image
MyAnimeList
MyMangaList
Past affiliations as QC/Proofreader: Kaitou Fansubs - Blood Lad, Strike the Blood, Attack on Ti.tan OVA
For-the-Halibut/Let It Go Scans: Hataraku Maou-sama!, Adam in Puberty, Kamisama Drops, Sekirei

Post Reply